I really enjoyed
Mad Max: Fury Road (a.k.a. the car chase movie with interesting female characters), so when I saw previews for
Atomic Blonde, another action film starring
Charlize Theron, I was excited. So before I saw the movie, I checked out the comic it was based on,
The Coldest City (the library's copy is retitled
Atomic Blonde: The Coldest City to tie in with the film release), and I can tell you that the comic and the movie are meant for different audiences.
The Coldest City was written by
Antony Johnston and illustrated by
Sam Hart. Hart's striking black and white artwork with its focus on the characters set the story's emotional tone for me as a reader. I admire Hart's use of shadows to convey the way that secrets were hidden and revealed. The plot was an unremarkable spy story with twists and double crosses I didn't find all that surprising, though the story's setting in Berlin just before the wall came down marking the beginning of the end of the Cold War was interesting.
The plot follows a hunt for a list of the true identity of all spies active in Europe (more or less a MacGuffin) and features a female character in a sea of men who underestimate her. Regardless of the book's historical setting, I expect more from a book written in 2012 than I do one written in 1989, and found this choice exhausting.
The film adaption largely removes the importance of sexism to the plot, and swaps two speaking roles from men to women. However, when you add in the film's increased emphasis on graphically violent action sequences, this change is problematic at best (
spoilers). The filmmakers also place a great deal of care into the
soundtrack and some strikingly colorful visuals, creating a very different tone from the comic.
The movie was okay, but I prefer action movies with an emphasis on fun over gritty (the above gif was maybe the only funny part). What I really appreciated about the film was the way it made me reexamine my experience of the comic. At first read,
The Coldest City seemed bland and predictable, but the movie helped me to appreciate its comparative subtlety and how the use of an unreliable narrator creates space for ambiguity.
~Sarah, Adult Services
